Dispelling the 1870 Brick Wall Myth: African American Ancestry Before the Federal Population Census

Dr. Shelley Viola Murphy
Apr 4, 2025
282 views
CC
SyllabusSyllabus
SyllabusSyllabus

About this webinar

A prevalent misconception in genealogy is the belief that African Americans cannot trace their ancestry beyond the 1870 Federal Population Census. This myth, known as the “1870 Brick Wall,” suggests that records of African American ancestors, especially those who were enslaved, are virtually non-existent before this key year. This presentation will debunk this myth by exploring the wealth of resources available for tracing African American lineage before 1870. Attendees will learn about various records, strategies, and techniques that can help uncover the rich histories of African American ancestors, challenging the notion that their genealogical journey must start in 1870.

About the speaker

An avid genealogist for over 40 years, Dr. Shelley Viola Murphy, aka "familytreegirl," was born and raised in Michigan, now living in central Virginia. She conducts genealogy workshops at local, state...
Learn more...

Key points and insights

In this powerful and resource-packed webinar, “Dispelling the 1870 Brick Wall Myth: African American Ancestry Before the Federal Population Census,” veteran genealogist Shelley Viola Murphy challenges one of the most persistent misconceptions in African American family history research—that it’s nearly impossible to trace enslaved or free Black ancestors prior to 1870. Through a compelling blend of historical context, methodology, and case studies, Murphy demonstrates that not only is it possible, but a wealth of records exists for those who know where and how to look. Her session equips genealogists with practical tools to explore African American lineage deeper than ever before.

Key Takeaways:
  • The 1870 Census Is a Starting Point—Not a Barrier: While the 1870 U.S. Census was the first to name formerly enslaved African Americans, Murphy makes clear that it should be viewed as a launching pad for deeper research. Clues such as surnames, proximity to former slaveholders, occupations, and household composition can help genealogists bridge the pre-emancipation gap using earlier sources.
  • A Wealth of Pre-1870 Records Is Hiding in Plain Sight: Researchers are encouraged to dig into record sets often overlooked: Freedmen’s Bureau documents, Freedman’s Bank records, apprenticeship laws, cohabitation registers, tax records, court documents, and even insurance policies on enslaved individuals. Each of these holds the potential to reveal names, relationships, and locations that pre-date emancipation.
  • Researching the Enslaver’s Family Is Often Key: Murphy emphasizes the critical importance of researching white families who enslaved or interacted with African Americans. Their wills, probate files, land transactions, and family trees often contain vital details about enslaved individuals, offering clues to lineage and migration patterns not recorded elsewhere.
This webinar offers a transformative perspective for anyone researching African American roots. By shedding light on historical laws, community context, and underutilized sources, Shelley Murphy empowers genealogists to bust through the so-called 1870 “brick wall” with confidence and precision.

To truly maximize your research potential, view the full webinar and explore the detailed syllabus materials. These resources go far beyond theory, providing actionable guidance and curated links that can guide you toward uncovering long-hidden branches of your family tree. Don’t let outdated myths limit your discoveries—tools and truth await.

Comments (32)

Sort byNewest
  1. WV
    Webinar Viewer
    10 months ago

    good information about an area that I had little knowlege.

  2. SW
    Shirlene Washington-Mack
    10 months ago

    Great resources, through presentation as always!

  3. MB
    Maureen Buttner-Jenkins
    10 months ago

    Fabulous resources discussed!

  4. SA
    SHIRLEY AIKIN
    10 months ago

    Thanks for the abundance of information and suggestions on where to go to search for enslaved ancestors.

  5. JM
    Julia Moten
    10 months ago

    BRILLIANT ... I am new to Family History and Genealogy so this greatly expands my knowledge base. Really loved how very organized and detailed presentation was. Listing the Record, Benefits, Who It Pertains To, How To Access and Examples. Can't say enough about Dr. Murphy's Presentation and knowledge. But she presents in a very effective manner that novice researchers can understand. And it goes beyond providing lots of knowledge. We have the tools to apply this knowledge to get results and records.

    1
  6. WV
    Webinar Viewer
    10 months ago

    Thank you for an informative session.

  7. WV
    Webinar Viewer
    10 months ago

    Awesome, Awesome presentation. She really know what it takes to break through the African American genealogy brick wall.

  8. CH
    Carol Harper
    10 months ago

    Dr. Murphy's webinar was phenomenal! She provided endless sources and great ideas for research. More importantly, Dr. Murphy was incredibly inspiring and enthusiastic about what could be found and why to keepon the quest and "in the box!" Thank you!

Related webinars

The Business of Enslavers: Acquiring Human Inventory
Play video01:20:49
The Business of Enslavers: Acquiring Human Inventory
Betsy Grant: A Fight for Freedom, Land, Education, and Love
Play video01:14:53
Southern Ancestors...Black and White...in the Freedmen's Bureau
Play video01:30:54
Introducing 10 Million Names
Play video00:43:20
Introducing 10 Million Names
311 views
CC
The Trifecta: Giving Light to the Lives of the Formerly Enslaved
Play video01:27:42
The Trifecta: Giving Light to the Lives of the Formerly Enslaved
284 views
CC