Finding Great-Granny’s Family: Four Words and DNA

Cathie Sherwood
Apr 8, 2025
614 views
CC
SyllabusSyllabus
SyllabusSyllabus

About this webinar

This case study illustrates how four simple words in a newspaper notice and DNA evidence became the key to unlocking Great Granny’s Irish roots. The research journey began with the cryptic phrase “Toowoomba papers please copy” in an 1886 death notice. This small clue directed the research to the Hanlon family in another location hundreds of kilometres away, with DNA evidence crucial to confirm the connection back to Kilkenny, Ireland. The presentation highlights the importance of scrutinising every detail in historical documents, no matter how small, and explores techniques for following unexpected leads across disparate locations, combining traditional research with DNA analysis.

About the speaker

Passionate about history and addicted to family history, Cathie has been researching her Irish, English and Scottish ancestors for over forty years. She was a university lecturer in digital technology...
Learn more...

Key points and insights

In this enlightening genealogy webinar, “Finding Great-Granny’s Family: Four Words and DNA,” Cathie Sherwood delivers an engaging case study that showcases the power of persistence, pattern recognition, and DNA analysis in family history research. With over 40 years of experience tracing Irish, English, and Scottish roots, Sherwood walks participants through her investigation into the mysterious origins of her great-grandmother, Annie Hanlon. What begins as a seemingly insignificant four-word phrase in an 1886 death notice evolves into a richly detailed exploration combining traditional records and genetic genealogy to build a compelling, evidence-based family narrative. This webinar is especially relevant for genealogists grappling with Irish ancestry, missing documentation, or long-standing research obstacles.

Key Takeaways:
  • Small Clues Can Lead to Major Breakthroughs. Sherwood’s journey began with a brief newspaper phrase—"Toowoomba papers please copy"—which became a crucial lead. Her meticulous analysis of newspaper notices, death certificates, immigration records, and church registers demonstrates how even minor details, when explored fully, can unlock family mysteries.
  • Combining Traditional Research with DNA Strengthens Hypotheses. By methodically layering civil registrations, land records, and historical maps with modern DNA tools like Ancestry’s ThruLines and WATO (What Are The Odds), Sherwood constructed a strong, if not definitive, case for Annie’s parentage. The integration of DNA clustering and segment comparison provided genetic support for suspected relationships among Hanlon siblings.
  • Naming Patterns, Nicknames, and Geographic Consistency Matter. The recognition of “Nancy” as a common nickname for “Annie,” paired with consistent mentions of County Kilkenny across records, allowed Sherwood to sift through conflicting data. These cultural nuances and localized patterns can be vital when navigating fragmented Irish genealogical sources.
Ready to uncover your own elusive ancestors? Watch the full webinar to follow Sherwood’s thoughtful, step-by-step approach. Her clear explanations of tools and methods offer valuable insights applicable to a wide range of genealogical challenges—especially those involving Irish heritage or missing parental data. Whether you're new to DNA analysis or seeking advanced techniques to solve a brick wall, this case study offers practical inspiration and strategic guidance.

Don’t forget to explore the full syllabus accompanying this session. It includes additional research tips, record examples, and resource links to help deepen your own investigations. The webinar and supporting materials are available through the Legacy Family Tree Webinars membership library, where thousands of expert-led classes await. Dive in, and take your family history further—one clue at a time.

Comments (30)

Sort byNewest
  1. EB
    Elizabeth Barnes
    9 months ago

    Margaret Born 1832’ William was abt 35, kind of late to be starting a family, are there other children before Margaret? When were William and Bridget married. Annie could be an earlier child’s child making her a granddaughter, and illegitimate which would lead to estrangement from her family.\nInteresting thought process and DNA analyses

    1
    1Reply
    • CS
      Cathie Sherwood
      9 months ago

      Good point Elizabeth, and one I had considered as I mention that scenario in the WATO discussion. Could there be a child before Margaret? Possibly but as yet DNA matches are not indicating that.

  2. HS
    Helen Schenkelaars
    9 months ago

    Great presentation and case study, very clear and easy to follow. I loved that it followed the actual research process, rather than presenting the finished research as you would get in a report.\nI also loved that the discoveries were based on paying attention to such a small detail and working the FAN club.

  3. KG
    Karen Gardner
    9 months ago

    This was a great help to me since I am trying to find elusive people in relation to my paternal great grandmother. I am also a Hanlon on maternal grandfather's side!

  4. WV
    Webinar Viewer
    9 months ago

    Great example of using DNA and traditional research to support your theory.

  5. MA
    Margaret Anderson
    9 months ago

    Excellent, easy to follow and understand.

  6. SG
    Sharren Grant
    9 months ago

    Excellent presentation.

  7. WV
    Webinar Viewer
    9 months ago

    Absolutely loved it - extremely helpful. Thankyou Cathie.

  8. WV
    Webinar Viewer
    9 months ago

    Could listen to that Aussie accent all day! Seriously, a very coherent presentation. Loved the graphics.

Related webinars

Can You Write a Wrong? Copyright in Australia
Play video00:56:48
Can You Write a Wrong? Copyright in Australia
199 views
CC
Education in Australia
Play video01:01:16
Education in Australia
192 views
CC
One Family, Many Connections: Using the FAN club in one Australian locality
Play video00:49:59
One Family, Many Connections: Using the FAN club in one Australian locality
438 views
CC